In a small barrier island resort town:
Judge: “You are charged with making an illegal turn on red. How do you plead?”
Defendant: “Not guilty by reason of insanity.”
Judge: “So you’re saying that you’re insane and the charges should be dismissed?”
Defendant: “Yes, Your Honor. These stupid traffic lights with no traffic are making me crazy!”
Judge: “So you’re saying that you think you can simply break the law at will if it doesn’t suit your needs?”
Defendant: “I thought this was stuff you asked me during testimony. I brought an expert witness who will be more than happy to attest to the ridiculous nature of these traffic signals.”
Judge: “Very well. Lets’ get on with this case. Officer Krupke will tell his version of the events first. Please take the stand, Officer. You swear to tell the truth and all that, don’t you?”
Krupke: “Pretty much. I can’t reveal any federal, state, or local secrets, however.”
Judge: “Do you know of any?”
Krupke: “I’ve heard of a lot of them. I just don’t know what they are. Well, except for the fact that the traffic signals are our biggest source of revenue, and the “No Turn on Red” sign was put up on a whim, but I can’t divulge any of that.”
Judge: “I thought the sign was on a standard signpost?”
Krupke: “No, I’m pretty sure it’s on a whim. That’s what I was told, but I’m not allowed to tell you that.”
Judge: “Just a whim, or more than one whim?”
Krupke: “Unless I’m mistaken, we’re talking multi-whims here.”
Judge: “Okay, whatever. Tell us what occurred on the night in question.”
Krupke: “I’m not sure whether or not it was night. It was two a.m., so I think that’s considered morning, not night, is it not?”
Judge: “We’ll get a ruling on that later. Did you happen to observe the defendant acting in a strange manner?”
Krupke: “Well, it seemed pretty strange to me.”
Defendant: “Objection! That leads to speculation!”
Judge: “No, it doesn’t. It is speculation. Sustained. I don’t know what we’re sustaining, but they only gave me ‘sustained’ and ‘overruled.’”
Krupke: “Okay, then I declare it as definitely strange. The defendant was traveling east and brought his vehicle to a complete stop, as required by the red color of the signal. He then proceeded to make a right turn in defiance of the signs posted on whims. I pursued him in a high-speed chase, although I’m the only one who drove at a high rate of speed. A low-speed chase is considered undignified in one of those souped-up cars they let us drive. I turned on my overhead lights and the defendant brought his car to a stop by the curb.”
Judge: “Did he have any ID?”
Krupke: “No, Your Honor. He said he didn’t know why I stopped him.”
Judge: “Idiot! I mean did he have any identification?”
Krupke: “Yes. He showed me his driver’s license, registration, and insurance card. This isn’t that important, but I also noticed that he’s a member in good standing of the Magic Kingdom Club.”
Judge: “Did he explain why he made the illegal turn?”
Krupke: “Not really. He said there was nothing coming for five miles, which is the length of the entire island.”
Judge: “Was he right?”
Krupke: “Yes and no. He was right that there was nothing coming, but he was wrong in making the turn before the signal turned to green. We only have a few intersections with “No Turn on Green” signs, and this wasn’t one of them. I read him his rights, then issued a summons.”
Judge: “You only have to read someone their rights if you arrest them.”
Krupke, laughing: “Oh, no, your honor, not those rights. I read him the law about not making rights on red when a sign is posted on a whim. I also informed him that it’s usually okay to make rights on green, with certain exceptions. While we’re here, I wanted to clear something up, for my own sake. Do we really have to READ people their rights, or is it okay to just recite them? I’m not a great reader, so it takes a while.”
Judge: “Don’t tell anyone I told you this, but I think it’s okay to pretend you’re reading. Did we establish motive? That’s usually important in proving your case. Never mind. I think you’ve submitted enough evidence already by showing me the traffic ticket. This is considered a moving violation, if I’m not mistaken.”
Krupke: “Right. If he didn’t move his vehicle he wouldn’t have incurred a violation.”
Judge: “Okay, let’s hear from the defendant. You can step down and listen for any contradictions.”
The defendant takes the stand.
Judge, after swearing in the defendant: “Okay, let’s hear what you have to say.”
Defendant: “Your Honor, in lieu of the circumstances, at two o’clock in the morning, with no traffic within five miles, I believe the officer should have used discretion in issuing a summons.”
Judge: “Well, I believe he did. He didn’t put it on the 11 o’clock news, or anything like that. I don’t think he even mentioned it to his fellow officers.”
Defendant: “What I mean is, it’s important to uphold the law, but it’s also important to determine whether or not my actions violated the spirit of the law. The obvious intention of these signs is to prevent traffic accidents. If no cars are visible within five miles, an accident can’t possibly occur.”
Judge: “I wouldn’t say that. You could have run into a pole, or a parked car.”
Defendant: “But I could have done that no matter what. Anyway, I thought that “No Turn on Red” meant if the light was red in the direction I was making the turn. This isn’t really explained on the signs.”
Judge: “Well, I suppose I’ll have to consider that during the sentencing phase of this trial. The jury should also consider that.”
Defendant: “Your Honor, this isn’t a trial, and there is no jury. This is traffic court.”
Judge: “I suppose you’re right. I’m not used to this, because you’re supposed to just come in and pay your fine. This is a whole new area for me.”
Defendant: “Your Honor, my contention is that these traffic signals serve no purpose during the winter months, because there is no traffic to speak of. The signals should either be turned off or changed to flashing signals.”
Judge: “We can’t change them to flashing signals. The lights would be red in the east-west direction, so you wouldn’t ever be able to make a right turn. I don’t think the municipality is prepared to pay its workers to remove those signs from the whims and put them up again in the spring.”
Defendant: “You could just put tape over the signs.”
Judge: “I’m not going to do anything like that! I’m a judge! That’s why we have a road department! Or maybe it’s Public Works, I’ll have to check on that. Anyway, who would pay for the tape?”
Defendant: “I’ll donate the tape, if it comes to that. Your Honor, I’d like to introduce my expert witness, Mr. Al Gore.”
Judge: “I don’t know what global warming has to do with this, but let him take the stand. I’m a little leery of this, because so far, I’m not so sure he’s ever told the truth about anything.”
Gore, after swearing in: “Your Honor, this municipality has a carbon footprint a thousand times bigger than that of Godzilla! It’s even bigger than mine! For over fifty years, cars have been sitting at traffic signals here, burning untold gallons of gas, polluting the air, and all for traffic that doesn’t exist! Traffic signals are intended to regulate traffic. If there’s no traffic, or very little traffic, they become gas-guzzling behemoths! And these “No Turn on Red” signs should be removed immediately! They’re not supposed to be put up on whims; they should be properly placed on signposts, and only where making a right turn on red would pose a danger because of lack of visibility. Of all places, this little seashore resort town will be among the first to succumb to the sea when all of the polar bears melt!”
Judge: “Your point is well-taken, but what does all that have to do with whether or not this individual blatantly violated the law of the land? Didn’t you once say something about the rule of law?”
Gore: “I don’t remember anything like that. If I did, it was during a campaign speech, or debate, or something like that, and none of those count. You can pretty much say anything during those times, and it’s okay. This is much more serious! We’re talking about the demise of an entire planet, just because some little insignificant police department wants to make it through the hard times during the winter. Well, there won’t be any hard times, or even any winter, if the entire planet goes up in flames, will there? It’s happening already in California, and will soon be making its way east. If you think this isn’t real, consider this: Just last week I observed several individuals in Pennsylvania eating pralines! Yes, global warming is on its way, and you’re not helping it with your stupid traffic lights!”
Judge: “I could find you in contempt, if I knew where it were, but luckily for you, I don’t. I could bring slander charges against you, because traffic lights are inanimate objects, so they can’t be stupid!”
Gore: “They’re only inanimate when they’re off, so they can be stupid when they’re on. They’re quite animated, you know.”
Judge: “Well, they’re pretty much a tradition here, and traditions either die slowly, or live forever. Business isn’t that great at the gas stations over the winter months, so it’s good that you pointed out that we’re helping them eke out a living. If I rule in favor of the defendant, can we keep most of the traffic lights on? The municipality will pick up your travel expenses, and we’ll let you make turns on red whenever you visit.”
Gore: “I don’t see how that will solve the global warming situation, but as long as you’re willing to pick up the tab for my jet, limo, and a couple of days of utility bills for my 20,000 square foot home, I just remembered something. Aren’t there salt marshes nearby?”
Judge: “Yes, the island is completely surrounded by salt marshes, at least on the west side.”
Gore: “Well, salt marshes teem with the red-tailed anorexic muskrat, which has a huge appetite for gold, making it virtually a living catalytic converter. These are what we call ‘carbon offsets.’”
Judge: “They’re anorexic? All along I figured they were bulimic, judging, no pun intended, by the strange odors coming from the marshes. There’s gold in the marshes?”
Gore: “No. They swim across the bay every night then skulk along the streets to the beach. On the beach, they dig for lost jewelry, so that explains the gold. In light of this development, I think we can mail you some carbon credits, which will reduce your carbon footprint considerably. The little critters themselves have rather small footprints, but you get the idea. You’ll have to supply an SASE, however.”
Judge: “Officer Krupke, do you have any objections to my dismissing the case for lack of evidence, or something like that? I can’t declare a mistrial if there’s no trial.”
Krupke: “I’m willing to make an exception, as long as I can get some carbon credits, too. I don’t have any envelopes handy, though.”
Gore: “I can send them all in one envelope. I’ll put your name on the ones for you. Your cooperation makes me feel all warm and fuzzy, and thankfully, it’s not due to any contribution to global warming on your part.”
Judge: “Case dismissed! The defendant is free to go, whenever the light is green.”